Despite what criminal charges an individual is facing, they have certain rights offered to them by the US constitution that need to be protected. However, in certain situations, a defendant may decide to waiver these rights before pleading guilty or no contest to a criminal offense. This is where the Tahl waiver comes in.
What Is The Tahl Waiver?
When an accused chooses to plead guilty or no contest to a criminal offense or offenses. They must choose to relinquish some of their constitutional rights. This renouncement of their rights is known as the Tahl waiver.
The Tahl waiver gets its name from the 1969 case, where the California Supreme Court Case expressed that for a guilty plea to be valid. The defendant must understand the constitutional rights that protect them and the consequences of waiving these rights before they voluntarily accept their plea.
To date, the Tahl waiver is used in misdemeanor and felony cases before a defendant can plead guilty or no contest to any criminal charges. Usually, the Tahl Waiver is formalized as a written agreement that informs the defendant of the rights they would be giving up and the repercussions of waiving these rights. The defendant is then expected to read the document, understand it and voluntarily sign it.
They will then have to appear before the judge who is presiding over their case.
The judge handling the case will then read the Tahl form and question whether the defendant is mentally clear on their rights, understands that they do not have to give them up, and is consciously aware of the ramifications of renouncing these rights. The judge questions the defendant to ensure that they delibaretely and willingly entered the plea bargain.
In most case, judges will demand a written Tahl form signed by the defendant. However, some judges will accept an oral plea bargain if the defendant is present in court.
For most misdemeanor cases, plea bargains can be accomplished outside of court, notarized, and entered into court by the defendant’s attorney, ensuring that the defendant never has to appear in court.
What Rights Do You Relinquish In A Tahl Waiver
Once the defendant chooses to sign the Tahl waiver, they willingly choose to relinquish three significant rights that are granted to them by the US constitution. These rights are:
The Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial. This right grants the accused criminal the right to a public and fair trial without delay by an impartial jury of their peers belonging to the state and district where the accused supposedly committed their crime.
The Sixth Amendment right to confront a witness. Commonly known as the confrontation clause, and assures the defendant the chance to face the witnesses in their criminal case and argue their testimony. This applies to statements made both inside and out of the court. This right allows a defendant to protect themselves against any damaging or false testimonies made by a witness.
The Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination. If you have ever heard a defendant plead the fifth, they were exercising their right against self-incrimination. This Fifth Amendment right grants a criminal defendant the right to refuse to be a witness against themselves. Thus, allowing the defendant the opportunity to refuse to take the witness stand, answer an incriminatory question, or make any incriminatory statements.
Can You Withdraw From A Guilty or No Contest Plea In A California Criminal Case?
Judges usually do everything in their power to ensure a defendant clearly understands the rights they are giving up before they can accept a guilty plea. This is because if a defendant does not enter a Tahl waiver willingly and voluntarily, the Tahl waiver may be considered defective, labeling a guilty plea invalid.
However, if a guilty or no consent plea is considered valid, a defendant can still choose to withdraw from the plea under the California Penal Code 1019 PC. This is possible if they file a Motion to Withdraw before they are sentenced or within six months of a probationary sentence and can show good cause for the Motion to Withdraw.
To prove good cause, the defendant must display clear and convincing evidence that they entered the plea because of some mistake, ignorance, inadvertence, incompetence, or some other reason that shows the defendant did not intentionally plan to accept a guilty plea.
All in all, a Tahl waiver ensures that a criminal defendant understands just what they would be giving up by waiving their rights, and they do this knowingly and voluntarily. If you need an attorney to help you recognize just what you would be giving up. You can contact our firm for expert advice.
Accused of a Crime and Need a Tahl Waiver?
You need an experienced lawyer to fight for your freedom and your rights.
Need a Criminal Defense Attorney? CALL NOW: 310-274-6529
Seppi Esfandi is an Expert Criminal Defense Attorney who has over 21 years of practice defending a variety of criminal cases.