Criminal Defense

Who Has More Influence Over a Criminal Case, Judge or Prosecutor?

October 22, 2021 by Seppi Esfandi in Criminal Defense  
Thumbnail for: Who Has More Influence Over a Criminal Case, Judge or Prosecutor?

Judge or Prosecutor

For many who think of a courtroom, the looming figure inside of it is the judge- sitting as an imposing figure in a black robe elevated above the rest of the players in the court room.

And for good reason too: the judge controls the calendar, presides over sentencing, and has the power to set bail.

However, this article is going to let you in on a little-known secret: in the vast majority of cases, the prosecutor has more power over the outcome of a criminal case that the judge.

The Judge’s role really becomes prominent during a criminal trial when the judge gets to decide what evidence comes in, what questions are allowed to be asked, and what objections are sustained or overruled. However, on a slim percentage of criminal cases go to trial- some estimates are around 2%. What that means is that 98% of cases are dismissed (8%), or end in a voluntary guilty plea by the defendant (90%).

Since 9 out of 10 cases will end in a guilty plea, the prosecutor’s role becomes magnified because the prosecutor is the one who has to agree to the deal (as well as the defendant). Once the prosecutor accepts the deal, the judge’s acceptance of the deal is essentially a rubber stamp.

The sentence in the State of California case is determined in conjunction with the prosecutor. The judge simply ‘rubber stamps’ it. Of course, as mentioned above, if the guilty verdict comes after a trial, then the judge’s power increases because the Judge has the sole power to sentence within the bounds of the law.

In Federal cases, the judge has more power to sentence with a plea deal because the deal is made without a sentence, and the sentencing comes later. However, the judge typically goes with the US Attorneys’ recommendation, or something close to it, evidencing once again that the prosecutor is the person to focus on.

Even when it comes to dismissals, with rare exception, it is the prosecutor who dismisses cases in the interest of justice, because they are unable to proceed, or because they’ve offered diversion.

There are a few exceptions where the judge’s power increases relative to the prosecutors:

Bail:

The Judge has the exclusive authority to set bail based on 2 factors:

  1. The defendant’s risk of fleeing or not showing up to court and
  2. the defendant’s risk to the community. Although the prosecutor makes a recommendation, the Judge holds the ultimate power.

Probation Violations:

If you are on probation, and pick up a new case, the judge has a much greater influence over your case because the judge exclusively determines if you violated probation (by a preponderance of the evidence) and can send you to jail on the probation violation with no further trial or agreement from the prosecutor.

Wobblers:

When a felony is a wobbler, that means it can be reduced down to a misdemeanor on the judge’s authority alone. Many times after a preliminary hearing, a defense attorney will ask for the case to be 17b’s, which refers to the PC 17(b)(5) where a Judge can reduce the felony to a misdemeanor, and sometimes do.

So in summary, in the exceptional case when there is a trial and a guilty plea, the judge has more influence over your case since you are at his or her mercy for the sentencing. However, in the 90% of cases where this is s a guilty plea bargain, the prosecutor holds much more influence over your fate, and it is the prosecutor who needs to be persuaded of your level of culpability. However, the judge holds much more power when bail is being set, when there are violations of probation and less, but still significant power, when the charge is a wobbler.

Arrested in Los Angeles?

A good criminal defense attorney can help you turn obstacles into fair chance success using the courts.

Need a Criminal Defense Attorney? CALL NOW: 310-274-6529

Seppi Esfandi is an Expert Criminal Defense Attorney who has over 20 years of practice defending a variety of criminal cases.

What if I Refuse to Testify in a Domestic Violence Case? Read our Client Reviews

Contact Us:         
Esfandi Law Group QR Code
Esfandi Law Group
Lara S.
December 3, 2019
5
Seppi had my case reduced to just an infraction, and thanks to him I was able to keep my job. Jorge was extremely helpful too, the reason I went with this law firm. Overall pleased.

How to Win Your Case

We cannot stress enough that you read, understand and follow these 10 basic rules if you are criminally charged or under investigation:

  1. Don’t ever talk to the police
  2. Do not discuss your case with anyone
  3. Everything you tell your lawyer is confidential
  4. Tell police you need to contact your attorney
  5. Never consent to any search by the police
  6. If the police knock on your door, don't answer!
  7. Realize the consequences of a criminal conviction
  8. Your lawyer (not you) will contact any witnesses
  9. Information on your cell phone is evidence
  10. Early Intervention is the key

Get a Free Consultation

    Free Consultation Form